1958 VFL Season: Brownlow Medal

Top 10 Players

Rank Player Team(s) Vote(s) 3 2 1
1st Neil Roberts St Kilda 24 5 4 1
2nd Brendan Edwards Hawthorn 22 5 3 1
3rd Bob Skilton South Melbourne 19 3 4 2
4th Allen Aylett North Melbourne 17 4 1 3
5th Bill Gunn South Melbourne 16 4 2 0
6th Johnny Birt Essendon 15 1 4 4
Jack Clarke Essendon 15 5 0 0
Jeff Gamble Essendon 15 3 2 2
9th Harry Sullivan Collingwood 14 3 2 1
Ted Whitten Footscray 14 3 2 1

*: Player was ineligible to receive the medal this season.

Team Summary

Rank Team Vote(s) Leader(s)
1st Collingwood 67 Harry Sullivan (14)
2nd Essendon 65 Johnny Birt, Jack Clarke, Jeff Gamble (15)
3rd Fitzroy 59 Owen Abrahams (13)
4th St Kilda 57 Neil Roberts (24)
5th South Melbourne 55 Bob Skilton (19)
Hawthorn 55 Brendan Edwards (22)
7th Geelong 52 Peter Falconer (11)
North Melbourne 52 Allen Aylett (17)
9th Carlton 51 John Benetti (12)
10th Footscray 49 Ted Whitten (14)
11th Melbourne 46 John Beckwith (11)
12th Richmond 40 Ron Branton (13)