1928 Semi Final 2 Replay: Collingwood v Melbourne

Match Details

Season: 1928 VFL Season
Round: Semi Final 2 Replay
Teams: Collingwood v Melbourne
Date: Saturday, September 22nd, 1928
Time: 2:30 PM
Venue: MCG
Attendance: 42,175
Capacity: unknown

Match Results

Outcome: Collingwood def. Melbourne
Score: 10.8.68 - 9.10.64

Quarter Breakdown

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final
Collingwood 2 . 2 3 . 3 5 . 7 10 . 8 10 . 8 (68)
Melbourne 1 . 4 1 . 6 3 . 8 9 . 10 9 . 10 (64)
Margin COL by 4 COL by 9 COL by 11 COL by 4 COL by 4
Duration 30:29 28:20 30:30 30:45 2:00:04

Honour Roll

Coach(es): Jock McHale (Collingwood), Ivor Warne-Smith (Melbourne)
Captain(s): Syd Coventry (Collingwood), Ivor Warne-Smith (Melbourne)

Match Umpires

Field Umpire(s): Jack McMurray
Goal Umpire(s):
Boundary Umpire(s):
Umpire Replacement(s): No known replacements

Player Statistics (Basic)

Collingwood

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
27 Andrew, Bruce WL ? 0 0
26 Angus, Les FPL ? 0 0
1 Beveridge, Jack C ? 1 0
3 Bowyer, Percy BPL ? 0 0
9 Chesswas, Harry CHF ? 0 1
4 Collier, Albert CHB ? 1 1
5 Collier, Harry FPR ? 2 1
7 Coventry, Gordon FF ? 0 1
8 Coventry, Syd RU ? 0 0
10 Dibbs, Charlie FB ? 0 0
12 Harris, John HFFR ? 1 2
14 Lauder, Albert BPR ? 0 0
13 Libbis, Billy RO ? 3 1
16 MacLeod, Norm WR ? 0 0
19 Makeham, Bob HBFL ? 2 1
18 Murphy, Frank HFFL ? 0 0
17 Murphy, Len RU ? 0 0
22 Rumney, Harold HBFR ? 0 0
Rushed 0
Total 10 8

Melbourne

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
4 Abernethy, Jim BPR ? 0 0
18 Barnes, Charlie C ? 0 0
17 Chadwick, Bert CHB ? 0 0
10 Collins, Jack BPL ? 0 0
29 Davidson, Jimmy RO ? 0 1
31 Deane, Col RU ? 1 1
28 Dunbar, Hugh FPR ? 0 0
16 Johnson, Bob FF ? 5 2
5 McConville, Tommy HFFR ? 0 1
32 Ogden, Gordon HBFR ? 0 0
35 Taylor, Dick WL ? 0 0
3 Thomas, Ted HBFL ? 0 0
26 Tymms, Bill FB ? 0 0
34 Usher, Ray WR ? 0 0
23 Vine, Frank CHF ? 1 1
14 Warne-Smith, Ivor RU ? 0 0
8 White, Herbie FPL ? 1 2
1 Wittman, Stan HFFL ? 1 2
Rushed 0
Total 9 10

Legend

ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CP: Contested Posessions, UP: Uncontested Posessions, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50s, MF: Marks Inside 50, RB: Running Bounces, OP: One-Percenters, GA: Goal Assists

Player Line-Up

Collingwood Coach: Jock McHale
BACK FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
10 J. Collins 26 B. Tymms 4 J. Abernethy 8 S. Coventry (c)

5 H. Collier 7 G. Coventry 26 L. Angus 17 L. Murphy

FORWARD 13 B. Libbis

HALF-BACK



3 T. Thomas 17 B. Chadwick 32 G. Ogden



12 J. Harris 9 H. Chesswas 18 F. Murphy



HALF-FORWARD



CENTRE



35 D. Taylor 18 C. Barnes 34 R. Usher



16 N. MacLeod 1 J. Beveridge 27 B. Andrew FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
CENTRE 31 C. Deane

HALF-FORWARD 14 I. Warne-Smith (c)

1 S. Wittman 23 F. Vine 5 T. McConville 29 J. Davidson

22 H. Rumney 4 A. Collier 19 B. Makeham



HALF-BACK



FORWARD



8 H. White 16 B. Johnson 28 H. Dunbar



14 A. Lauder 10 C. Dibbs 3 P. Bowyer



BACK



Melbourne Coach: Ivor Warne-Smith

Score Timeline

Quarter Team Scoring Event Score Time
Q1 MEL Bob Johnson behind 0.0.0 - 0.1.1 ??:??
COL Billy Libbis behind 0.1.1 - 0.1.1 ??:??
MEL Frank Vine behind 0.1.1 - 0.2.2 ??:??
COL Harry Collier behind 0.2.2 - 0.2.2 ??:??
MEL Tommy McConville behind 0.2.2 - 0.3.3 ??:??
MEL Jimmy Davidson behind 0.2.2 - 0.4.4 ??:??
COL Harry Collier goal 1.2.8 - 0.4.4 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson goal 1.2.8 - 1.4.10 ??:??
COL John Harris goal 2.2.14 - 1.4.10 ??:??
Q2 COL Harry Chesswas behind 2.3.15 - 1.4.10 ??:??
COL Harry Collier goal 3.3.21 - 1.4.10 ??:??
MEL Col Deane behind 3.3.21 - 1.5.11 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson behind 3.3.21 - 1.6.12 ??:??
Q3 COL unknown behind 3.4.22 - 1.6.12 ??:??
COL unknown behind 3.5.23 - 1.6.12 ??:??
MEL Stan Wittman behind 3.5.23 - 1.7.13 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson goal 3.5.23 - 2.7.19 ??:??
MEL Frank Vine goal 3.5.23 - 3.7.25 ??:??
MEL Herbie White behind 3.5.23 - 3.8.26 ??:??
COL Bob Makeham behind 3.6.24 - 3.8.26 ??:??
COL John Harris behind 3.7.25 - 3.8.26 ??:??
COL Bob Makeham goal 4.7.31 - 3.8.26 ??:??
COL Jack Beveridge goal 5.7.37 - 3.8.26 ??:??
Q4 COL Albert Collier behind 5.8.38 - 3.8.26 ??:??
COL Albert Collier goal 6.8.44 - 3.8.26 ??:??
MEL Stan Wittman behind 6.8.44 - 3.9.27 ??:??
MEL Herbie White behind 6.8.44 - 3.10.28 ??:??
MEL Herbie White goal 6.8.44 - 4.10.34 ??:??
COL Bob Makeham goal 7.8.50 - 4.10.34 ??:??
COL Billy Libbis goal 8.8.56 - 4.10.34 ??:??
COL Billy Libbis goal 9.8.62 - 4.10.34 ??:??
MEL Col Deane goal 9.8.62 - 5.10.40 ??:??
MEL Stan Wittman goal 9.8.62 - 6.10.46 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson goal 9.8.62 - 7.10.52 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson goal 9.8.62 - 8.10.58 ??:??
COL Billy Libbis goal 10.8.68 - 8.10.58 ??:??
MEL Bob Johnson goal 10.8.68 - 9.10.64 ??:??