1898 VFL Season Round-Robin Final 3: South Melbourne v Carlton

This is the match report for the match played on 10 September 1898 between South Melbourne and Carlton during the third round-robin final round of the 1898 season of the Victorian Football League. South Melbourne hosted Carlton at Lakeside Oval. Bill Fraser captained the hosts with Dick Gibson as vice-captain. Ernie Walton captained the visitors with Peter Williams as vice-captain.

South Melbourne (6.11.47) defeated Carlton (3.4.22).

Match Details

Season: 1898 VFL Season
Round: Third Round-Robin Final
Teams: South Melbourne v Carlton
Date: Saturday 10 September 1898
Time: 2:30 PM
Venue: Lakeside Oval

Match Results

Outcome: South Melbourne def. Carlton
Score: 6.11.47 - 3.4.22

Quarter Breakdown

	Q1			Q2			Q3			Q4			Final
South Melbourne	0	.	1	3	.	4	5	.	8	6	.	11	6	.	11	(47)
Carlton	0	.	2	0	.	2	2	.	2	3	.	4	3	.	4	(22)
Margin	CARL by 1			SMLB by 20			SMLB by 24			SMLB by 25			SMLB by 25
Duration

Honour Roll

South Melbourne

Captain: Bill Fraser
Vice-Captain: Dick Gibson

Carlton

Captain: Ernie Walton
Vice-Captain: Peter Williams

Match Umpires

Field Umpires

S. Hood

Goal Umpires

W. Goer
C. Thomas

Player Statistics

South Melbourne

#	Player	Pos.	ToG%	GL	BH
	Adamson, Dave	?	?	0	?
	Armstrong, Warwick	?	?	0	?
	Burns, Allen	?	?	1	?
	Cornelius, George	?	?	0	?
	Davidson, George	?	?	0	?
	Davis, Johnny	?	?	2	?
	Fraser, Bill (c)	?	?	0	?
	Gibson, Dick (vc)	?	?	1	?
	Gilligan, Tom	?	?	0	?
	Howson, Bert	?	?	0	?
	Jeanneret, Henri	?	?	0	?
	McNair, Arch	?	?	0	?
	O'Hara, Frank	?	?	0	?
	O'Hara, Jack	?	?	1	?
	Pleass, Mick	?	?	1	?
	Purdy, Harry	?	?	0	?
	Robertson, Val	?	?	0	?
	Southern, Jack	?	?	0	?
	Trim, Albert	?	?	0	?
	Windley, Bill	?	?	0	?
Rushed					?
Total (20 players)				6	11

Carlton

#	Player	Pos.	ToG%	GL	BH
	Casey, Bill	?	?	0	?
	Considine, Pat	?	?	0	?
	Curtis, Charlie	?	?	0	?
	Dohrmann, Herman	?	?	0	?
	Donaghy, Mick	?	?	0	?
	Douglas, Jack	?	?	0	?
	Dunne, Henry	?	?	0	?
	Morrison, Len	?	?	1	?
	O'Cock, Wally	?	?	1	?
	Pender, Jim	?	?	0	?
	Reekie, Jack	?	?	0	?
	Sharkey, Bill	?	?	0	?
	Stewart, Dick	?	?	0	?
	Sweatman, Charlie	?	?	0	?
	Vernon, Les	?	?	1	?
	Walsh, Bobby	?	?	0	?
	Walton, Ernie (c)	?	?	0	?
	Warde, George	?	?	0	?
	Williams, Peter (vc)	?	?	0	?
	Young, George	?	?	0	?
Rushed					?
Total (20 players)				3	4

Legend

ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50s

Score Timeline

Quarter	Team	Scoring Event	Score			Time
Q1		unknown behind	0.?.?	-	0.?.?	??:??
		unknown behind	0.?.?	-	0.?.?	??:??
		unknown behind	0.1.1	-	0.2.2	??:??
Q2	SMLB		?.?.?	-	0.2.2	??:??
	SMLB		?.?.?	-	0.2.2	??:??
	SMLB		?.?.?	-	0.2.2	??:??
	SMLB		?.?.?	-	0.2.2	??:??
	SMLB		?.?.?	-	0.2.2	??:??
	SMLB		3.4.22	-	0.2.2	??:??
Q3			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.2.?	??:??
			5.8.38	-	2.2.14	??:??
Q4			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			?.?.?	-	?.?.?	??:??
			6.11.47	-	3.4.22	??:??

Links

1898 VFL Season

The information provided on this site does not necessarily align with the official record. The purpose of this site is to present its author's attempt to amalgamate a variety of sources of information on the VFL/AFL, VFA/VFL, SANFL, WAFL, TSL and other competitions to provide its users a unified view of the people (e.g. players, coaches, draftees and umpires), places, events (e.g. matches, drafts and awards) and other entities that have contributed to the rich history of Australian rules football.