1898 VFL Round-Robin Final 3: South Melbourne v Carlton

This is the match report for the match played on 10 September 1898 between South Melbourne and Carlton during the third round-robin final round of the 1898 VFL season. South Melbourne hosted Carlton at Lakeside Oval. Bill Fraser captained the hosts with Dick Gibson as vice-captain. Ernie Walton captained the visitors with Peter Williams as vice-captain.

South Melbourne
B. Fraser (capt.), D. Gibson (vice-capt.), D. Adamson, W. Armstrong, A. Burns, G. Cornelius, G. Davidson, J. Davis, T. Gilligan, B. Howson, H. Jeanneret, A. McNair, F. O'Hara, J. O'Hara, M. Pleass, H. Purdy, V. Robertson, J. Southern, A. Trim, B. Windley

Carlton
E. Walton (capt.), P. Williams (vice-capt.), B. Casey, P. Considine, C. Curtis, H. Dohrmann, M. Donaghy, J. Douglas, H. Dunne, L. Morrison, W. O'Cock, J. Pender, J. Reekie, B. Sharkey, D. Stewart, C. Sweatman, L. Vernon, B. Walsh, G. Warde, G. Young

South Melbourne (6.11.47) defeated Carlton (3.4.22).

Goalkickers
South Melbourne: J. Davis (2), A. Burns, D. Gibson, J. O'Hara, M. Pleass
Carlton: L. Morrison, W. O'Cock, L. Vernon

Match Details

Season: 1898 VFL Season
Round: Round-Robin Final 3
Teams: South Melbourne v Carlton
Date: Saturday 10 September 1898
Time: 2:30 PM
Venue: Lakeside Oval

Match Results

Outcome: South Melbourne def. Carlton
Score: 6.11.47 - 3.4.22

Quarter Breakdown

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final
South Melbourne 0 . 1 3 . 4 5 . 8 6 . 11 6 . 11 (47)
Carlton 0 . 2 0 . 2 2 . 2 3 . 4 3 . 4 (22)
Margin CARL by 1 SMLB by 20 SMLB by 24 SMLB by 25 SMLB by 25
Duration

Honour Roll

Coaches: unknown (South Melbourne), unknown (Carlton)
Captains: Bill Fraser (South Melbourne), Ernie Walton (Carlton)
Vice-Captains: Dick Gibson (South Melbourne), Peter Williams (Carlton)

Match Umpires

Field Umpire: S. Hood
Goal Umpire: W. Goer, C. Thomas

Player Statistics

South Melbourne

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Adamson, Dave ? ? 0 ?
Armstrong, Warwick ? ? 0 ?
Burns, Allen ? ? 1 ?
Cornelius, George ? ? 0 ?
Davidson, George ? ? 0 ?
Davis, Johnny ? ? 2 ?
Fraser, Bill (c) ? ? 0 ?
Gibson, Dick (vc) ? ? 1 ?
Gilligan, Tom ? ? 0 ?
Howson, Bert ? ? 0 ?
Jeanneret, Henri ? ? 0 ?
McNair, Arch ? ? 0 ?
O'Hara, Frank ? ? 0 ?
O'Hara, Jack ? ? 1 ?
Pleass, Mick ? ? 1 ?
Purdy, Harry ? ? 0 ?
Robertson, Val ? ? 0 ?
Southern, Jack ? ? 0 ?
Trim, Albert ? ? 0 ?
Windley, Bill ? ? 0 ?
Rushed ?
Total (20 players) 6 11

Carlton

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Casey, Bill ? ? 0 ?
Considine, Pat ? ? 0 ?
Curtis, Charlie ? ? 0 ?
Dohrmann, Herman ? ? 0 ?
Donaghy, Mick ? ? 0 ?
Douglas, Jack ? ? 0 ?
Dunne, Henry ? ? 0 ?
Morrison, Len ? ? 1 ?
O'Cock, Wally ? ? 1 ?
Pender, Jim ? ? 0 ?
Reekie, Jack ? ? 0 ?
Sharkey, Bill ? ? 0 ?
Stewart, Dick ? ? 0 ?
Sweatman, Charlie ? ? 0 ?
Vernon, Les ? ? 1 ?
Walsh, Bobby ? ? 0 ?
Walton, Ernie (c) ? ? 0 ?
Warde, George ? ? 0 ?
Williams, Peter (vc) ? ? 0 ?
Young, George ? ? 0 ?
Rushed ?
Total (20 players) 3 4

Legend

ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50s

Score Timeline

Quarter Team Scoring Event Score Time
Q1 unknown behind 0.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
unknown behind 0.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
unknown behind 0.1.1 - 0.2.2 ??:??
Q2 SMLB ?.?.? - 0.2.2 ??:??
SMLB ?.?.? - 0.2.2 ??:??
SMLB ?.?.? - 0.2.2 ??:??
SMLB ?.?.? - 0.2.2 ??:??
SMLB ?.?.? - 0.2.2 ??:??
SMLB 3.4.22 - 0.2.2 ??:??
Q3 ?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.2.? ??:??
5.8.38 - 2.2.14 ??:??
Q4 ?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
6.11.47 - 3.4.22 ??:??