1899 VFL Round 5: Carlton v Collingwood

This is the match report for the match played on 3 June 1899 between Carlton and Collingwood during round 5 of the 1899 VFL season. Carlton hosted Collingwood at Princes Park. Henry McShane captained the hosts with Bill Stuckey as vice-captain. Bill Proudfoot captained the visitors with Dick Condon as vice-captain.

Carlton
Back: A. Thompson, B. Bird, B. Stuckey (vice-capt.)
Half-back: H. McShane (capt.), E. Walton, B. McNamara
Centre: J. Hooper, B. Casey, C. Curtis
Half-forward: D. Lanigan, P. Williams, D. Walker
Forward: P. Considine, B. Churchyard, W. O'Cock
Follower: L. Morrison, G. Young, B. Monagle

Collingwood
Back: B. Rush, B. Proudfoot (capt.), M. Fell
Half-back: G. Williams, J. Monohan, B. O'Brien
Centre: C. Pannam, F. Leach, C. Sime
Half-forward: A. Tame, A. Leach, J. Ryan
Forward: T. Carmody, A. Smith, L. Tulloch
Follower: W. Fell, F. Hailwood, D. Condon (vice-capt.)

Carlton (3.3.21) were defeated by Collingwood (7.10.52).

Goalkickers
Carlton: B. Churchyard, W. O'Cock, D. Walker
Collingwood: A. Leach (2), L. Tulloch (2), T. Carmody, D. Condon, A. Smith

As a result of this match, Carlton remained 8th on the ladder and Collingwood were then 4th on the ladder (up from 5th) by the end of the round.

Match Details

Season: 1899 VFL Season
Round: Round 5
Teams: Carlton v Collingwood
Date: Saturday 3 June 1899
Time: 3:00 PM
Venue: Princes Park

Match Results

Outcome: Carlton def. by Collingwood
Score: 3.3.21 - 7.10.52

Quarter Breakdown

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final
Carlton 3 . 1 3 . 1 3 . 2 3 . 3 3 . 3 (21)
Collingwood 1 . 2 3 . 6 5 . 10 7 . 10 7 . 10 (52)
Margin CARL by 11 COLL by 5 COLL by 20 COLL by 31 COLL by 31
Duration

Honour Roll

Coaches: unknown (Carlton), unknown (Collingwood)
Captains: Henry McShane (Carlton), Bill Proudfoot (Collingwood)
Vice-Captains: Bill Stuckey (Carlton), Dick Condon (Collingwood)

Match Umpires

Field Umpire: D. Gibson
Goal Umpire: J. Lucas, R. Turpenny

Player Statistics

Carlton

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Bird, Bob FB ? 0 ?
Casey, Bill C ? 0 ?
Churchyard, Bill FF ? 1 ?
Considine, Pat FPL ? 0 ?
Curtis, Charlie WR ? 0 ?
Hooper, John WL ? 0 ?
Lanigan, Denis HFFL ? 0 ?
McNamara, Bill HBFR ? 0 ?
McShane, Henry (c) HBFL ? 0 ?
Monagle, Billy RO ? 0 ?
Morrison, Len RU ? 0 ?
O'Cock, Wally FPR ? 1 ?
Stuckey, Bill (vc) BPR ? 0 ?
Thompson, Arthur BPL ? 0 ?
Walker, Dick HFFR ? 1 ?
Walton, Ernie CHB ? 0 ?
Williams, Peter CHF ? 0 ?
Young, George RU ? 0 ?
Rushed ?
Total (18 players) 3 3

Collingwood

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Carmody, Tom FPL ? 1 ?
Condon, Dick (vc) RO ? 1 ?
Fell, Matthew BPR ? 0 ?
Fell, Wilfred RU ? 0 ?
Hailwood, Frank RU ? 0 ?
Leach, Arthur CHF ? 2 ?
Leach, Fred C ? 0 ?
Monohan, Jack CHB ? 0 ?
O'Brien, Bill HBFR ? 0 ?
Pannam, Charlie WL ? 0 ?
Proudfoot, Bill (c) FB ? 0 ?
Rush, Bob BPL ? 0 ?
Ryan, Jimmy HFFR ? 0 ?
Sime, Charlie WR ? 0 ?
Smith, Archie FF ? 1 ?
Tame, Alby HFFL ? 0 ?
Tulloch, Lardie FPR ? 2 ?
Williams, George HBFL ? 0 ?
Rushed ?
Total (18 players) 7 10

Legend

ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50s

Player Line-Up

Carlton Coach: unknown
BACK FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
B. Rush B. Proudfoot (c) M. Fell L. Morrison

W. O'Cock B. Churchyard P. Considine G. Young

FORWARD B. Monagle

HALF-BACK



G. Williams J. Monohan B. O'Brien



D. Walker P. Williams D. Lanigan



HALF-FORWARD



CENTRE



C. Pannam F. Leach C. Sime



C. Curtis B. Casey J. Hooper FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
CENTRE W. Fell

HALF-FORWARD F. Hailwood

A. Tame A. Leach J. Ryan D. Condon (vc)

B. McNamara E. Walton H. McShane (c)



HALF-BACK



FORWARD



T. Carmody A. Smith L. Tulloch



B. Stuckey (vc) B. Bird A. Thompson



BACK



Collingwood Coach: unknown