1905 VFL Semi Final 2: Collingwood v Carlton
This is the match report for the match played on 16 September 1905 between Collingwood and Carlton in the second semi final of the 1905 VFL season.
Collingwood hosted Carlton at MCG.
Charlie Pannam captained the hosts with Jack Monohan as vice-captain.
Jim Flynn captained the visitors.
The hosts were coached by Dick Condon and the visitors were coached by Jack Worrall.
Collingwood
C. Pannam (capt.), J. Monohan (vice-capt.), G. Angus, D. Condon, E. Drohan, A. Dummett, D. Fraser, P. Gibb, G. Green, A. Leach, G. Marsh, J. McHale, B. Nash, P. Ogden, H. Pears, B. Rush, F. Stancliffe, B. Strachan
Carlton
J. Flynn (capt.), B. Boyle, G. Bruce, F. Caine, N. Clark, F. Elliott, M. Grace, C. Hammond, G. Johnson, J. Kennedy, T. Kennedy, R. McGregor, A. McNeel, B. Parke, B. Payne, C. Roland, A. Snell, G. Topping
Collingwood (4.6.30) were defeated by Carlton (11.10.76).
Goalkickers
Collingwood: D. Condon, G. Green, B. Nash, F. Stancliffe
Carlton: J. Kennedy (2), C. Roland (2), G. Topping (2), F. Caine, F. Elliott, J. Flynn, M. Grace, G. Johnson
Match Details
Season:
1905 VFL Season
Round:
Semi Final 2
Teams:
Collingwood
v
Carlton
Date:
Saturday 16 September 1905
Time:
2:30 PM
Venue:
MCG
Attendance:
14,000
Match Results
Outcome:
Collingwood
def. by
Carlton
Score:
4.6.30 - 11.10.76
Quarter Breakdown
| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Final | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collingwood | 0 | . | 1 | 0 | . | 3 | 2 | . | 4 | 4 | . | 6 | 4 | . | 6 | (30) |
| Carlton | 4 | . | 3 | 5 | . | 5 | 8 | . | 7 | 11 | . | 10 | 11 | . | 10 | (76) |
| Margin | CARL by 26 | CARL by 32 | CARL by 39 | CARL by 46 | CARL by 46 | |||||||||||
| Duration | ||||||||||||||||
Honour Roll
Coaches:
Dick Condon
(Collingwood),
Jack Worrall
(Carlton)
Captains:
Charlie Pannam
(Collingwood),
Jim Flynn
(Carlton)
Vice-Captains:
Jack Monohan
(Collingwood),
unknown
(Carlton)
Match Umpires
Field Umpire:
I. Crapp
Player Statistics
Collingwood
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Angus, George | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Condon, Dick | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Drohan, Eddie | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Dummett, Alf | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Fraser, Don | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Gibb, Percy | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Green, George | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Leach, Arthur | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Marsh, George | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| McHale, Jock | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Monohan, Jack (vc) | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Nash, Bob | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Ogden, Percy | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Pannam, Charlie (c) | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Pears, Harry | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Rush, Bob | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Stancliffe, Fred | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Strachan, Bob | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (18 players) | 4 | 6 | |||
Carlton
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boyle, Bob | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Bruce, George | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Caine, Frank | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Clark, Norm | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Elliott, Fred | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Flynn, Jim (c) | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Grace, Mick | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Hammond, Charlie | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Johnson, George | ? | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Kennedy, Jim | ? | ? | 2 | ? | |
| Kennedy, Ted | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| McGregor, Rod | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| McNeel, Archie | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Parke, Bert | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Payne, Billy | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Roland, Charlie | ? | ? | 2 | ? | |
| Snell, Archie | ? | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Topping, George | ? | ? | 2 | ? | |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (18 players) | 11 | 10 | |||