1908 VFL Season Semi Final 2: Carlton v St Kilda

This is the match report for the match played on 19 September 1908 between Carlton and St Kilda in the second semi final of the 1908 season of the Victorian Football League. Carlton hosted St Kilda at the MCG. Fred Elliott captained the hosts. Dave McNamara captained the visitors. The hosts were coached by Jack Worrall and the visitors were coached by Mick Grace.

Carlton (12.12.84) defeated St Kilda (3.8.26).

Match Details

Season: 1908 VFL Season
Round: Second Semi Final
Teams: Carlton v St Kilda
Date: Saturday 19 September 1908
Time: 2:30 PM
Venue: MCG
Attendance: 25,531

Match Results

Outcome: Carlton def. St Kilda
Score: 12.12.84 - 3.8.26

Quarter Breakdown

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final
Carlton 4 . 1 8 . 7 8 . 10 12 . 12 12 . 12 (84)
St Kilda 0 . 3 0 . 4 0 . 5 3 . 8 3 . 8 (26)
Margin CARL by 22 CARL by 51 CARL by 53 CARL by 58 CARL by 58
Duration

Honour Roll

Carlton

Captain: Fred Elliott
Coach: Jack Worrall

St Kilda

Captain: Dave McNamara
Coach: Mick Grace

Match Umpires

Field Umpires

H. Coombes

Boundary Umpires

J. O'Loughlin
H. Palling

Player Statistics

Carlton

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Beck, Les FB ? 0 ?
Bruce, George WL ? 0 ?
Clark, Norm BPL ? 0 ?
Elliott, Fred (c) RO ? 2 ?
Flynn, Jim HBFL ? 0 ?
Ford, Arthur BPR ? 1 ?
Gardiner, Vin FF ? 4 ?
Gotz, Martin HFFR ? 1 ?
Hammond, Charlie RU ? 0 ?
Jinks, Fred HBFR ? 0 ?
Johnson, George RU ? 0 ?
Kelly, Harvey FPL ? 1 ?
Kennedy, Ted WR ? 1 ?
Lang, Alex HFFL ? 1 ?
Marchbank, Jim CHF ? 0 ?
McGregor, Rod C ? 0 ?
Payne, Billy CHB ? 0 ?
Topping, George FPR ? 1 ?
Rushed ?
Total (18 players) 12 12

St Kilda

# Player Pos. ToG% GL BH
Bant, Horrie CHB ? 0 ?
Barwick, Vic FB ? 0 ?
Cowell, Jim HFFR ? 1 ?
Cumberland, Vic RU ? 0 ?
Dangerfield, Gordon HBFL ? 0 ?
Feehan, Dan HBFR ? 0 ?
Gant, Wally BPL ? 0 ?
Grace, Mick FPL ? 1 ?
Hall, Harry WR ? 0 ?
Julian, Jack BPR ? 0 ?
Lever, Harry HFFL ? 1 ?
Madden, Bill FPR ? 0 ?
McNamara, Dave (c) CHF ? 0 ?
Morrissey, George RO ? 0 ?
Scott, Wally WL ? 0 ?
Stewart, Billy C ? 0 ?
Stewart, Jim FF ? 0 ?
Woodcock, Bill RU ? 0 ?
Rushed ?
Total (18 players) 3 8

Legend

ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50s

Player Line-Up

Carlton Coach: Jack Worrall
BACK FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
W. Gant V. Barwick J. Julian C. Hammond

G. Topping V. Gardiner H. Kelly G. Johnson

FORWARD F. Elliott (c)

HALF-BACK



G. Dangerfield H. Bant D. Feehan



M. Gotz J. Marchbank A. Lang



HALF-FORWARD



CENTRE



W. Scott B. Stewart H. Hall



T. Kennedy R. McGregor G. Bruce FOLLOWER INTERCHANGE
CENTRE V. Cumberland

HALF-FORWARD B. Woodcock

H. Lever D. McNamara (c) J. Cowell G. Morrissey

F. Jinks B. Payne J. Flynn



HALF-BACK



FORWARD



M. Grace J. Stewart B. Madden



A. Ford L. Beck N. Clark



BACK



St Kilda Coach: Mick Grace

Score Timeline

Quarter Team Scoring Event Score Time
Q1 ?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
4.1.25 - 0.3.3 ??:??
Q2 ?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
8.7.55 - 0.4.4 ??:??
Q3 unknown behind 8.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
unknown behind 8.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
unknown behind 8.?.? - 0.?.? ??:??
unknown behind 8.10.58 - 0.5.5 ??:??
Q4 ?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
?.?.? - ?.?.? ??:??
12.12.84 - 3.8.26 ??:??