1910 VFL Semi Final 2: Carlton v South Melbourne
This is the match report for the match played on 17 September 1910 between Carlton and South Melbourne in the second semi final of the 1910 VFL season.
Carlton hosted South Melbourne at MCG.
Fred Elliott captained the hosts.
Bill Thomas captained the visitors.
The hosts were coached by Fred Elliott and the visitors were coached by Bill Thomas.
Carlton
Back:
D. Harris, B. Goddard, T. McCluskey
Half-back:
N. Clark, B. Payne, P. Sheehan
Centre:
T. Clancy, R. McGregor, E. Jamieson
Half-forward:
J. Wells, J. Marchbank, J. Baquie
Forward:
A. Wilson, V. Gardiner, A. McDonald
Follower:
F. Elliott (capt.), J. Flynn, M. Gotz
South Melbourne
Back:
B. Streckfuss, B. Dolphin, A. Punshon
Half-back:
T. Grimshaw, B. Thomas (capt.), A. Pentland
Centre:
J. Prince, G. Bower, A. Gough
Half-forward:
B. Sloss, B. Deas, A. Hiskins
Forward:
L. Mortimer, J. Cameron, F. Carpenter
Follower:
D. Barry, V. Belcher, A. Kerr
Carlton (6.17.53) were defeated by South Melbourne (10.5.65).
Goalkickers
Carlton: M. Gotz (2), F. Elliott, V. Gardiner, J. Marchbank, A. McDonald
South Melbourne: F. Carpenter (4), L. Mortimer (2), J. Cameron, B. Deas, A. Hiskins, A. Kerr
Match Details
Season:
1910 VFL Season
Round:
Semi Final 2
Teams:
Carlton
v
South Melbourne
Date:
Saturday 17 September 1910
Time:
2:30 PM
Venue:
MCG
Attendance:
41,271
Match Results
Outcome:
Carlton
def. by
South Melbourne
Score:
6.17.53 - 10.5.65
Quarter Breakdown
| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Final | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carlton | 1 | . | 4 | 2 | . | 11 | 5 | . | 12 | 6 | . | 17 | 6 | . | 17 | (53) |
| South Melbourne | 2 | . | 1 | 5 | . | 2 | 7 | . | 5 | 10 | . | 5 | 10 | . | 5 | (65) |
| Margin | SMLB by 3 | SMLB by 9 | SMLB by 5 | SMLB by 12 | SMLB by 12 | |||||||||||
| Duration | ||||||||||||||||
Honour Roll
Coaches:
Fred Elliott
(Carlton),
Bill Thomas
(South Melbourne)
Captains:
Fred Elliott
(Carlton),
Bill Thomas
(South Melbourne)
Match Umpires
Field Umpire:
J. Elder
Boundary Umpire:
J. Davidson,
J. Dwyer
Player Statistics
Carlton
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baquie, Jack | HFFR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Clancy, Tom | WL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Clark, Norm | HBFL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Elliott, Fred (c) | RU | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Flynn, Jim | RU | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Gardiner, Vin | FF | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Goddard, Bill | FB | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Gotz, Martin | RO | ? | 2 | ? | |
| Harris, Dick | BPL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Jamieson, Ernie | WR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Marchbank, Jim | CHF | ? | 1 | ? | |
| McCluskey, Tom | BPR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| McDonald, Andy | FPR | ? | 1 | ? | |
| McGregor, Rod | C | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Payne, Billy | CHB | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Sheehan, Percy | HBFR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Wells, Jack | HFFL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Wilson, Archie | FPL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (18 players) | 6 | 17 | |||
South Melbourne
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barry, Dave | RU | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Belcher, Vic | RU | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Bower, George | C | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Cameron, Jim | FF | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Carpenter, Fred | FPR | ? | 4 | ? | |
| Deas, Bob | CHF | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Dolphin, Bill | FB | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Gough, Alf | WR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Grimshaw, Tom | HBFL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Hiskins, Arthur | HFFR | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Kerr, Alex | RO | ? | 1 | ? | |
| Mortimer, Len | FPL | ? | 2 | ? | |
| Pentland, Alan | HBFR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Prince, Joe | WL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Punshon, Arthur | BPR | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Sloss, Bruce | HFFL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Streckfuss, Bert | BPL | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Thomas, Bill (c) | CHB | ? | 0 | ? | |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (18 players) | 10 | 5 | |||
Legend
ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50sPlayer Line-Up
| Carlton | Coach: Fred Elliott | ||||||||||||||
| BACK | FOLLOWER | INTERCHANGE | |||||||||||||
| B. Streckfuss | B. Dolphin | A. Punshon | F. Elliott (c) |
|
|
||||||||||
| A. McDonald | V. Gardiner | A. Wilson | J. Flynn |
|
|
||||||||||
| FORWARD | M. Gotz |
|
|
||||||||||||
| HALF-BACK |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| T. Grimshaw | B. Thomas (c) | A. Pentland |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| J. Baquie | J. Marchbank | J. Wells |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| HALF-FORWARD |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| CENTRE |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| J. Prince | G. Bower | A. Gough |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| E. Jamieson | R. McGregor | T. Clancy | FOLLOWER | INTERCHANGE | |||||||||||
| CENTRE | D. Barry |
|
|
||||||||||||
| HALF-FORWARD | V. Belcher |
|
|
||||||||||||
| B. Sloss | B. Deas | A. Hiskins | A. Kerr |
|
|
||||||||||
| P. Sheehan | B. Payne | N. Clark |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| HALF-BACK |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| FORWARD |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| L. Mortimer | J. Cameron | F. Carpenter |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| T. McCluskey | B. Goddard | D. Harris |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
| BACK |
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||
| South Melbourne | Coach: Bill Thomas | ||||||||||||||