1958 VFL Round 12: Carlton v Melbourne
This is the match report for the match played on 28 June 1958 between Carlton and Melbourne during round 12 of the 1958 VFL season.
Carlton hosted Melbourne at Princes Park.
Bruce Comben captained the hosts.
In the absence of John Beckwith, vice-captain Ron Barassi captained the visitors.
The hosts were coached by Jim Francis and the visitors were coached by Norm Smith.
Carlton
B. Comben (capt.), B. Arch, P. Barry, D. Beasy, J. Benetti, G. Burke, J. Chick, K. Clarke, B. Crowe, G. Donaldson, G. Ferry, G. Gilchrist, J. Heathcote, J. James, L. Kerr, G. McColl, D. Nicholls, S. Silvagni, J. Sullivan, P. Webster
Melbourne
R. Barassi (capt.), F. Adams, K. Carroll, G. Case, B. Dixon, D. Fenton-Smith, B. Johnson, D. Jones, J. Lord, P. Marquis, I. McLean, L. Mithen, G. Pinfold, I. Ridley, A. Rowarth, G. Tunbridge, B. Turner, A. Webb, D. Williams, C. Wilson
Carlton (9.14.68) were defeated by Melbourne (12.12.84).
Goalkickers
Carlton: B. Crowe (2), G. Donaldson (2), G. Burke, J. Heathcote, D. Nicholls, S. Silvagni, J. Sullivan
Melbourne: R. Barassi (3), A. Webb (3), G. Case (2), B. Johnson, J. Lord, A. Rowarth, B. Turner
As a result of this match, Carlton remained 9th on the ladder and Melbourne remained 1st on the ladder by the end of the round.
Match Details
Season:
1958 VFL Season
Round:
Round 12
Teams:
Carlton
v
Melbourne
Date:
Saturday 28 June 1958
Time:
2:15 PM
Venue:
Princes Park
Attendance:
23,833
Quarter Breakdown
| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Final | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carlton | 0 | . | 3 | 2 | . | 6 | 3 | . | 10 | 9 | . | 14 | 9 | . | 14 | (68) |
| Melbourne | 0 | . | 3 | 1 | . | 7 | 8 | . | 11 | 12 | . | 12 | 12 | . | 12 | (84) |
| Margin | level | CARL by 5 | MELB by 31 | MELB by 16 | MELB by 16 | |||||||||||
| Duration | ||||||||||||||||
Honour Roll
Coaches:
Jim Francis
(Carlton),
Norm Smith
(Melbourne)
Captains:
Bruce Comben
(Carlton),
Ron Barassi
(Melbourne)
Match Umpires
Field Umpire:
J. Irving
Player Statistics
Carlton
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 | Arch, Bill | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 18 | Barry, Peter | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 17 | Beasy, Doug | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 8 | Benetti, John | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 5 | Burke, Gerald | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 23 | Chick, John | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 16 | Clarke, Kevin | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 15 | Comben, Bruce (c) | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 14 | Crowe, Bob | ? | ? | 2 | ? |
| 13 | Donaldson, Graham | ? | ? | 2 | ? |
| 25 | Ferry, George | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 28 | Gilchrist, Graham | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 37 | Heathcote, John | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 10 | James, John | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 11 | Kerr, Laurie | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 36 | McColl, Graham | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 12 | Nicholls, Don | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 20 | Silvagni, Serge | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 30 | Sullivan, Jack | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 3 | Webster, Peter | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (20 players) | 9 | 14 | |||
Melbourne
| # | Player | Pos. | ToG% | GL | BH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Adams, Frank | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 31 | Barassi, Ron (ac) | ? | ? | 3 | ? |
| 19 | Carroll, Keith | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 7 | Case, Geoff | ? | ? | 2 | ? |
| 9 | Dixon, Brian | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 1 | Fenton-Smith, Dick | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 16 | Johnson, Bob | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 27 | Jones, Dennis | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 4 | Lord, John | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 3 | Marquis, Peter | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 5 | McLean, Ian | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 11 | Mithen, Laurie | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 20 | Pinfold, Graeme | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 24 | Ridley, Ian | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 2 | Rowarth, Alan | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 23 | Tunbridge, Geoff | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 10 | Turner, Bob | ? | ? | 1 | ? |
| 15 | Webb, Athol | ? | ? | 3 | ? |
| 25 | Williams, Don | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| 33 | Wilson, Colin | ? | ? | 0 | ? |
| Rushed | ? | ||||
| Total (20 players) | 12 | 12 | |||
Legend
ToG%: Time-on-Ground Percentage, GL: Goals, BH: Behinds, DI: Disposals, KI: Kicks, HB: Handballs, MK: Marks, HO: Hitouts, TA: Tackles, CL: Clearances, CR: Clangers, FF: Free Kicks For, FA: Free Kicks Against, RF: Rebounds Inside 50, IF: Inside 50sScore Timeline
| Quarter | Team | Scoring Event | Score | Time | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | unknown behind | 0.?.? | - | 0.?.? | ??:?? | |
| unknown behind | 0.?.? | - | 0.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| unknown behind | 0.?.? | - | 0.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| unknown behind | 0.?.? | - | 0.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| unknown behind | 0.?.? | - | 0.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| unknown behind | 0.3.3 | - | 0.3.3 | ??:?? | ||
| Q2 | ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| 2.6.18 | - | 1.7.13 | ??:?? | |||
| Q3 | ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| 3.10.28 | - | 8.11.59 | ??:?? | |||
| Q4 | ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | ||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| ?.?.? | - | ?.?.? | ??:?? | |||
| 9.14.68 | - | 12.12.84 | ??:?? | |||